Second opinions That Evaluation Didn’t Feel Right. Here’s What to Do Next.
You left the office with a stack of papers and a sinking feeling.
Maybe the psychologist spent 45 minutes with your child – rushed, checking boxes and told you she’s “not on the spectrum.” But you’ve watched your daughter for months or years trying to get through a school day, and you know. Or maybe you’re an adult who finally got up the nerve to seek answers after a lifetime of feeling different, only to get a report back that reads like it’s describing a stranger.
Your intuition is worth listening to.
Getting an evaluation takes courage, money, and time. Leaving with results that feel wrong, incomplete, or dismissive can be devastating. You deserve the truth.
Why So Many Evaluations Miss the Mark
The standard picture of autism was built on a narrow foundation. For a long time, research focused almost exclusively on young white boys with obvious social differences. Which means the field spent decades developing tools that are reasonably good at identifying one kind of autism and much less reliable for everyone else.
- Women
- Girls
- People of color
- Adults who’ve spent years learning to mask
- Transgender and nonbinary individuals
- People who were adopted
- Anyone who’s held it together on the outside while quietly struggling on the inside
- People with a PDA profile

These are the people who fall through the cracks most often. Their experience differs from the “typical” autism profile, so most evaluations are not equipped to find them.
If you are seeking understanding of PDA, Pathological Demand Avoidance / Persistent Drive for Autonomy, a profile that many clinicians still don’t fully understand or even recognize, there are even more challenges. If you were wondering about PDA but it was never raised during your evaluation, or if it got waved away by the clinician, there’s a real chance the picture you received is incomplete.
There are a lot of reasons why this may be the case, but the biggest is that there has been a huge amount of change in the field and understanding of autism, and the education and understanding of many clinicians has not caught up.
How Do You Know It’s Time for a Second Opinion?
There’s no single rule for when a second opinion may be warranted, but these are signs it’s worth a second look:
- You were told “not autistic” and everything in your gut disagrees
- The evaluation felt rushed, or like the evaluator had already made up their mind before meeting you
- PDA was never brought up, or was dismissed quickly
- The report doesn’t match how your child actually behaves at home, or how you actually move through the world
- You got a diagnosis, but no one explained what it actually means for your daily life
- The recommendations felt copy-pasted generic suggestions that could apply to anyone
- You don’t know how to talk to your child about the report, because the report doesn’t sound like your child
When an evaluation truly captures who someone is, it becomes a tool for self-understanding, for advocating for the right supports, for finally making sense of things. When it doesn’t, it just sits in a drawer.

A Second Opinion Doesn’t Mean Starting Over
This is what stops a lot of people: the fear that seeking a second opinion means going through the whole exhausting process again. It usually doesn’t.
Depending on what you already have and what you’re trying to figure out, there are a few different paths:
Full Re-Evaluation is the right move when the original assessment was too limited to be useful when you need a complete, thorough picture from the ground up.
Targeted Assessment fills in specific gaps. If part of the evaluation was solid but PDA was never considered, or certain questions were never asked, a focused assessment can address exactly that without repeating everything.
Record Review + Consultation is often the right first step when you’re not sure what you need. I review the prior report carefully, identify what was missed or misread, and give you clear, specific recommendations often without any additional testing at all.
What We Do Differently
We’re not here to confirm or argue with someone else’s conclusions. We’re here to understand the person in front of us.
That means going beyond standardized scores. It means knowing what high-masking looks like in a teenage girl who’s held it together at school for years while falling apart at home. It means understanding PDA well enough to recognize it when it’s present including in people who’ve learned to hide it. It means knowing that autism looks different across gender, culture, age, and background, and bringing that knowledge into every evaluation.
We work with adults and children, including many who have been told “no” before. Our evaluations are thorough, individualized, and grounded in a genuine effort to understand.

Not Sure What You Need? Start Here.
If you’re not sure whether you need a full re-evaluation, a targeted assessment, or just a conversation about what you’re looking at, we offer a free 15-minute consultation to help you figure it out.
We’ll look at what you already have, listen to what felt off, and tell you honestly what we think the right next step is. Sometimes that’s a full re-evaluation. Sometimes it’s a focused consultation. Sometimes we can answer your questions in those 15 minutes alone.
→ Schedule your free 15-minute consultation
Dr. Jessica Myszak and Dr. Jaime Long have significant experience performing psychological evaluations with children and adults. They offer both in-person and telehealth evaluations for children, teens, and adults looking for answers. In addition to seeing clients on the Chicago North Shore, they are able to work with families who reside in Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, Washington DC, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming! If you are interested in learning more about potentially working with them, you can visit their website here to get the process started.

























